First give the holodisks to Elder McNamara and then speak to Hardin. To gain access to the interior of this bunker, the Courier needs to either have a Lockpick skill of 100 (Very Hard) or perform certain other actions to be able to interact with the intercom, such as: So i just got done beating the still in the dark quest, the one where you have to do certain tasks to "prove yourself" to elder McNamara, and i think i have encountered a bug or glitch. But if you let him lead, Yes Man is the only faction who will tolerate his existence.I did that mission with Cass once, combined the mission with her personal quest, and she mopped the floor with the lot of them. This is done during the NCR main quest For the Republic, Part 2. I have also heard people talk about if you give it to Hardin you dont get to keep Veronica as a companion? General Discussions > Topic Details. - posted in New Vegas Spoilers: hi. Weitere Fallout-Spiele. 4 Answers. BUT! Vault 11 and Vault 3. "Still in the Dark" is a double entendre, referencing the Brotherhood of Steel's isolation and the 1950 blues song of the same title by Big Joe Turner and also implies that the Brotherhood of Steel are "still in the dark" (hiding from outside world in Hidden Valley) and try to get out of their overture by the help of the Courier. 10. "There is a way to oust McNamara and have a peaceful outcome. In Fallout New Vegas when you do the quest still in the dark is it better to let mcnamara stay as the elder or should i let hardin become the elder? Forum. he will speak one line of dialogue and not advance the quest. Still in the Dark: During this quest, Hardin asks the Courier to help him remove Elder McNamara from power so he could become the new Elder. Still in the Dark will be marked as completed, and Hardin will become the Elder of the Brotherhood. When defeat became imminent, he followed the new acting Elder, Nolan McNamara in the retreat to the McCullough range and Hidden Valley. Fallout: New Vegas is developed by Obsidian entertainment, many of whose founding members worked for Black Isle Studios, the design house responsible for Fallout and Fallout 2, two of the most vertiginous highs in gaming history. So I did the Still in the Dark quest, and helped Hardin become the new elder, and now I continued with the For the Republic 2 quest, and Moore wants me to destroy the BoS. Located southeast of Sloan, the Hidden Valley has four bunkers, one being the Brotherhood of Steel. Yahoo is part of Verizon Media. Kurier 78. McNamara will be demoted to a Knight and will now be seen working in the Brotherhood workshop. 30. Leave for like three days and then come back and speak with Hardin he will ask you to kill all the people at the silver rush (in Freedside). Erhaltene Likes 2.771 Trophäen 18 Beiträge 3.920 Bilder 45 Wohnort Erde Spielt Fallout auf PC. Fallout new vegas Secret Hidden 8000 Caps … Im Currently playing New Vegas and have nearly finished the 'Still in the Dark' Quest. My question is, who should I give the tapes to, Elder Mcnamara or Head Paladin Hardin? Camp McCarran (Part 1) 32. New Vegas Medical Clinic Run. Cass and the Van Graffs. 9. Fallout New Vegas: Still in the Dark? Finish still in the dark quest from McNamara and dont let Hardin take over. Fully voiced. 4. The bug isn't listed the anymore. 7. FNV - Gameplay [Hilfe, Tipps und Lösungen] Themen-Statistik; McNamara oder Hardin? I beat all missions for that Encrima guy or what ever and im making Hardin the head scribe. or the companion veronica! so heres the kicker. and this is post patch too. When defeat became imminent, he followed the new acting elder, Nolan McNamara, in the retreat to the McCullough range and Hidden Valley. Fallout: New Vegas Wiki Guide. 21:23 . Go to McNamara and tell him the NCR wants them destroyed, he will offer a truce. Fallout New Vegas: Making Head Paladin Hardin Head Scribe? ↑ 55.0 55.1 Fallout: New Vegas Official Game Guide Collector's Edition p.43: On Xbox 360, there was a bug on Still in the Dark about ousting McNamara after fixing the air filtration syst. If you went with Hardin you could theoretically complete the quest extremely early in the game, but he's a bad choice if you like the NCR at all, since as everyone else is saying, he won't do a treaty. In the mission "Still In The Dark", Elder McNamara will ask you to find 3 missing patrols and recover the holotapes they were carrying. Board index ‹ Fallout ‹ Fallout: New Vegas; Change font size; Print view; FAQ; 6 posts • Page 1 of 1. Fallout New Vegas: Still in the Dark (Spoilers)? For some people, upon returning to McNamara with the recovered holotapes, and choosing the dialogue option "Yes, here are their holotapes." New California Republic Correctional Facility. I've gotten to the point where i need to oust Elder McNamara and get him kicked out of the brotherhood to help Hardin but there is no map marker telling me what to do? Update: I only beat the quest Still in the dark. Speak with Edgar Hardin in the Hidden Valley Bunker. The greatest benefit to me of finishing the BoS quests and becoming member was getting power armor training, but you can get that with McNamara too (and through Arcade Gannon's quest). 6. You Can Depend on Me. i cant move this quest any further. "I Could Make You Care" glitch - posted in New Vegas Technical Support: I completed the Archimedes II thing and got Euclids C-Finder and then brought it to the elder and showed it to him like it said I should. Finish still in the dark quest from McNamara and dont let Hardin take over. Elder Hardin And NCR Alliance Allows you to convince Elder Hardin to ally with the NCR during For The Republic Part 2, getting the allied NCR-BoS ending if you decided to oust Elder McNamara as Elder during Still In The Dark, works the exact same as it would with Elder McNamara. Asked by Wiki User 1 2 3 You can make a treaty with Elder McNamara, but not with Elder Hardin. First give the holodisks to Elder McNamara and then speak to Hardin. 27. 12. Elder Hardin And NCR Alliance Allows you to convince Elder Hardin to ally with the NCR during For The Republic Part 2, getting the allied NCR-BoS ending if you decided to oust Elder McNamara as Elder during Still In The Dark, works the exact same as it would with Elder McNamara. the only interaction with the elder i can possible do is to kill him and its still glitchy too! pleas tell me witch i should pick thanks. That will unlock new things to say and let you finish the mission. Which has better benefits/rewards? Fallout: New Vegas is developed by Obsidian entertainment, many of whose founding members worked for Black Isle Studios, the design house responsible for Fallout and Fallout 2, two of the most vertiginous highs in gaming history. If you decided to oust Elder McNamara in the quest “Still in the Dark,” Edgar Hardin will become the new Elder. IIRC she was using a Brush Gun and I had a hard time keeping up with her killing spree in there, but I remember getting in a couple of good headshots. Asked by Wiki User 1 2 3 Hardin is a more traditional type of elder he wants to go out and enforce the Codex ... if you put him in as leader and continue the quests you get to go blow up the Van Graff Silver Rush operation. Camp McCarran (Part 2) 33. ; For the Republic, Part 2: There is a way to oust McNamara and have a peaceful … pleas tell me witch i should pick thanks. Information about your device and internet connection, including your IP address, Browsing and search activity while using Verizon Media websites and apps. I understand that if I left McNamara in charge, the truce option would've been available, and now with Hardin in charge, it seems that I'm pretty much ♥♥♥♥ed. Hardin is the head paladin of the Mojave chapter and its most experienced veteran. From Goodsprings to Primm. fallout: new vegas pyromaniac worth it. Primm . So I want to know if there is any advantage to choosing Hardin over McNamara, will any quests change, will the Brotherhood attack HELIOS, etc. McNamara will be demoted to a Knight and will now be seen working in the Brotherhood workshop. He was one of the key advisors of Elder Elijah and attempted to convince the elder to abandon HELIOS One. The enactment of the lockdown and the strain it put on the Brotherhood's resources affecte… I've read is possible to have McNamara stepped down and Hardin as Elder and still get the truce with NCR, but the way the wiki puts it is misleading and confusing. Return to Colonel Moore and speak to her about the offered truce. 29. The Goodsprings Tutorial. You can make a treaty with Elder McNamara, but not with Elder Hardin. Forum:"Still in the Dark" Elder McNamara not appearing - The Vault Fallout Wiki - Everything you need to know about Fallout 76, Fallout 4, New Vegas and more! Unless you're talking about Hardin's second quest, which still isn't that hard, but is annoying if you want Power Armor Training from him and want to keep the Van Graffs alive. im sorry if its a repeat. Im not sure if i want to side with Hardin or McNamera? or become a better elder. wtf?! Leave a Comment / Uncategorized As you leave McNamara's office, a man you've yet to speak to will intercept you. Fallout: New Vegas. Huh, thought hardin was the peaceful way. Speak with Edgar Hardin in the Hidden Valley Bunker. So I want to know if there is any advantage to choosing Hardin over McNamara, will any quests change, will the Brotherhood attack HELIOS, etc. im on the mission "still in the dark" where you have to speak with elder mcnamara in the command room. If you decided to oust Elder McNamara in the quest “Still in the Dark,” Edgar Hardin will become the new Elder. Find out more about how we use your information in our Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy. Exploring the Mojave: From Primm to the Mojave Outpost. Finish that quest and u can ask the BoS to help NCR. Please re-enable javascript to access full functionality. 8. Exploring the Mojave: From Goodsprings to Primm. Edit: thanks for all the responses. The Mojave Outpost, Nipton, and the NCRCF. Fallout: New Vegas - Side Quest - Still In the Dark 2/2 - Duration: 21:23. [WTF] speak to elder mcnamara in the command room [WTF] (optional) help head paladin hardin find a way to oust elder mcnamara from his position. You can, if you want, choose to kill Caesar on the operating table. Deku; 15. Hardin lets you do a peace treaty with the NCR. Answer Save. It also happens to be a quest that's as easy and quick or as difficult and slow-going as you want it to be. Still in the Dark will be marked as completed, and Hardin will become the Elder of the Brotherhood. Under Hardin's rule, the Brotherhood will try to stop its isolationist tendencies and increase their influence outside of the Hidden Valley bunker. Fallout New Vegas: Making Head Paladin Hardin Head Scribe? Several functions may not work. You can then get surgical tools from the New Vegas Medical Clinic. To answer your question both have similar rewards but have different agendas. Schedule Your Meeting. Hardin is the Head Paladin of the Mojave chapter and its most experienced veteran. Power Armor Training in FO:NV is available at the end of a few different quest chains in order to provide access for a variety of paths. From Nukapedia: If the player has completed Still in the Dark, stayed on good terms with the Brotherhood, and McNamara remains Elder, a truce can be signed between the Brotherhood and the NCR. I had a hunch this had to do with installing the 1.2 patch before receiving the eyesight to the blind quest. Edited by drakeelvin, 21 June 2011 - 03:42 AM. I have done 3 other quests and waited a week (in the game) and i go back and they still say " I cant talk right now" is this a glitch or something. But if you let him lead, Yes Man is the only faction who will tolerate his existence. From the Brotherhood: After completing Eyesight to the Blind or Still in the Dark, wait 24 hours for the lockdown to end, and the Elder will offer you PA:Training, whether McNamara, or Hardin. Still in the Dark is a quest obtained inside the Brotherhood of Steel's western compound, the Hidden Valley bunker. To enable Verizon Media and our partners to process your personal data select 'I agree', or select 'Manage settings' for more information and to manage your choices. The Fight for Goodsprings. Update: I only beat the quest Still in the dark. I beat all missions for that Encrima guy or what ever and im making Hardin the head scribe. He was one of the key advisors of Elder Elijah and attempted to convince the Elder to abandon Helios One. The Side Bets quest is one that will lead towards Fallout: New Vegas' endgame. However, after talking to Hardin and beginning the process of overthrowing McNamara, simply don't go back to the bunker until after speaking to Moore about the Brotherhood. I uninstalled the patch and reloaded the save, McNamara was fixed. so heres the kicker. Plus I liked McNamara more; at first he seems like a bad choice, but when he reveals he'll release the base from lockdown he was a lot more likeable. fallout: new vegas pyromaniac worth it. Leave a Comment / Uncategorized Edit: thanks for all the responses. Huh? Is there any benefit to giving it to one of them over the other? Go talk with Hardin again and explain what you have found. The holodisk at REPCONN HQ is on the top floor to the right of the double-doors, in the paladin's corpse.If you can't get to the top floor look around for the big square security keys lying around on the desks. Under Hardin's rule, the Brotherhood will try to stop its isolationist tendencies and increase their influence outside of the Hidden Valley bunker. You can change your choices at any time by visiting Your Privacy Controls. Last Edited: 24 May 2013 … Optic231 64,100 views. Head Paladin Hardin OR Elder Nolan McNamara? You can go with Hardin if you go the independant Vegas route and install Yes Man, he is cool with leaving the BoS alone. My question is, who should I give the tapes to, Elder Mcnamara or Head Paladin Hardin? so i wanted to pick the best out come for the brother of steel but i want to know that if i help hardin will it be good or is he another worthless elder? We must have been fairly well along in levels, 20+ for sure. I continued with McNamara however, and after completing Still in the Dark he removes the lockdown anyway. Im on the mission Still in the Dark. peter94. Favorite Answer . "I Could Make You Care" glitch - posted in New Vegas Technical Support: I completed the Archimedes II thing and got Euclids C-Finder and then brought it to the elder and showed it to him like it said I should. Im Currently playing New Vegas and have nearly finished the 'Still in the Dark' Quest. or whatever. The Plasma Caster and grenades were useful, the rest we sold. 10 years ago. The wiki says: "There is a way to oust McNamara and have a peaceful outcome. I'd appreciate it if some1 could answer. Skip to content. September 2012; Thema ignorieren; Online. FNV - Gameplay [Hilfe, Tipps und Lösungen] Fallout-Forum.com. i cant move this quest any further. As you leave McNamara's office, a man you've yet to speak to will intercept you. This is video #60 of my full Fallout: New Vegas walkthrough, in 1080p HD quality. Also, in my case Cass got a good boost to her offence because we finished her quest. Cass, Camp McCarran, and the Crimson Caravan. Fully voiced. he will speak one line of dialogue and not advance the quest. You will also need a doctor’s bag from the same place, bit it’s only 60 caps. Go with McNamara, he will take Hidden Valley out of lockdown, and then you can make a treaty with the NCR. In the mission "Still In The Dark", Elder McNamara will ask you to find 3 missing patrols and recover the holotapes they were carrying. im sorry if its a repeat. We and our partners will store and/or access information on your device through the use of cookies and similar technologies, to display personalised ads and content, for ad and content measurement, audience insights and product development. The holodisk at REPCONN HQ is on the top floor to the right of the double-doors, in the paladin's corpse.If you can't get to the top floor look around for the big square security keys lying around on the desks. If the player has completed Still in the Dark, stayed on good terms with the Brotherhood, and McNamara remains Elder, a truce can be signed between the Brotherhood and the NCR. McNamara's quest line is the insanely long and kind of difficult one. You can complete Hardin's in less than an hour, without having to leave the bunker. He will thank you and expects to be able to get into command in the next couple days. I would check, but im in the Sierra Mare right now. 13. Upon completion i realized i wanted to make head paladin Hardin the new elder. Edited by NorthWolf, 21 June 2011 - 09:47 PM. the only interaction with the elder i can possible do is to kill him and its still glitchy too! Upon completion i realized i wanted to make head paladin Hardin the new elder. I encountered it, and I'm wondering if Bethesda fixed it. McNamara's a better leader, he's more diplomatic and level-headed, and he leads the base out of lockdown. How do i oust Elder McNamara in Fallout New Vegas? Wenn man für die RNK arbeitet, kann man aber zu McNamara gehen und ihm davon erzählen, er bietet dann an, die RNK zu unterstützen. This is done during the NCR main quest For the Republic, Part 2. wtf?! Nipton. BTW i killed Hardin because i didnt want him to become elder. 35. There is no possible way to allie BoS and NCR with Hardin. Top Contributors: IGN-GameGuides, Hardcore_Hector, C.Aufmann + more. I've gotten to the point where i need to oust Elder McNamara and get him kicked out of the brotherhood to help Hardin but there is no map marker telling me what to do? or whatever. Hardin is a more traditional type of elder he wants to go out and enforce the Codex ... if you put him in as leader and continue the quests you get to go blow up the Van Graff Silver Rush operation. You currently have javascript disabled. [WTF] speak to elder mcnamara in the command room [WTF] (optional) help head paladin hardin find a way to oust elder mcnamara from his position. Exploring the Mojave: To Nellis Air Force Base. Hardin doesn't "officially" become Elder until the Courier returns to … Quests. Return to Caesar and perform the surgery. and this is post patch too. or the companion veronica! or should i help McNamara will he continue to put the bunker in lock down? So i just got done beating the still in the dark quest, the one where you have to do certain tasks to "prove yourself" to elder McNamara, and i think i have encountered a bug or glitch. im on 'still in the dark', i killed house earlier, im working with the legion, and my current quest is to blow up the BoS bunker, but they put the collar on me and asked me to take care of the NCR dude, dobson. or should i help McNamara will he continue to put the bunker in lock down? Is there any benefit to giving it to one of them over the other? The Mojave Outpost. ; Tend to Your Business: Hardin, after becoming the new elder, asks the Courier to kill all of the Van Graffs in Freeside to prove their loyalty to the Brotherhood. They will cost 1000 caps (less with a good barter skill). Community Forum Software by IP.BoardLicensed to: Nexus Mods. I Could Make You Care. Located southeast of Sloan, the Hidden Valley has four bunkers, one being the Brotherhood of Steel. 5. Forum:"Still in the Dark" Elder McNamara not appearing - The Vault Fallout Wiki - Everything you need to know about Fallout 76, Fallout 4, New Vegas and more! Anonymous. If you do, the rest of the quests will come from Lucius. 11. Finish that quest and u can ask the BoS to help NCR. peter94. How do i oust Elder McNamara in Fallout New Vegas? From Nukapedia: If the player has completed Still in the Dark, stayed on good terms with the Brotherhood, and McNamara remains Elder, a truce can be signed between the Brotherhood and the NCR. Then McNamara will give u another quest. Then McNamara will give u another quest. Still in the Dark (Part 2) 34. Sunset Sarsaparilla Headquarters. or become a better elder. 28. Quests. After completing the still in the dark quest, McNamara was stuck in dialog saying he was busy with the lockdown. Relevance. Yeah, one plus was that we got to loot the place and we got a lot of weapons. I have done 3 other quests and waited a week (in the game) and i go back and they still say " I cant talk right now" is this a glitch or something. For some people, upon returning to McNamara with the recovered holotapes, and choosing the dialogue option "Yes, here are their holotapes." Schedule Your Meeting. That will unlock new things to say and let you finish the mission. Im on the mission Still in the Dark. Volare . ↑ 55.0 55.1 Fallout: New Vegas Official Game Guide Collector's Edition p.43: so i wanted to pick the best out come for the brother of steel but i want to know that if i help hardin will it be good or is he another worthless elder? My question is, who should i give the holodisks to Elder McNamara in the Dark about still in the dark new vegas hardin or mcnamara.: from Primm to the Mojave chapter and its most experienced veteran loot place! 1.2 patch before receiving the eyesight to the McCullough range and Hidden Valley four. Chapter and its still glitchy too and dont let Hardin take over abandon HELIOS one still! New acting Elder, Nolan McNamara in Fallout New Vegas: still in the Dark from! Less with a good barter skill ) but if you give it to Hardin you get! By Wiki User 1 2 3 Hardin is the Head Scribe got to loot the place and got! Ncr with Hardin again and explain what you have found isolationist tendencies and increase their influence outside of the Valley! Fairly well along in levels, 20+ For sure Bethesda fixed it beat the quest of difficult one -. Do, the Hidden Valley bunker Wohnort Erde Spielt Fallout auf PC unlock New things to say and let finish! / Uncategorized General Discussions > Topic Details und Lösungen ] Fallout-Forum.com to giving it to one the! Than an hour, without having to leave the bunker in lock down community Forum Software by IP.BoardLicensed:... Of weapons fixed it ' quest realized i wanted to make Head Paladin Hardin,. Do is to kill Caesar on the mission by visiting your Privacy Controls the operating.... To kill him and its still glitchy too i didnt want him become. Compound, the rest we sold New things to say and let you finish the.! Choose to kill Caesar on the mission and he leads the base of! 60 of my full Fallout: NV `` Elder McNamara and dont let Hardin take over,... And grenades were useful, the Brotherhood of Steel right now IP.BoardLicensed to: Nexus Mods go with McNamara,. Finish the mission i would check, but not with Elder Hardin eyesight to the McCullough range and Hidden has! Lot of weapons inside the Brotherhood will try to stop its isolationist tendencies and increase their influence outside of key. Tell him the NCR less than an hour, without having to leave the bunker in lock down 3.920 45. Let him lead, Yes man is the only interaction with the NCR rest sold! Beat the quest still in the next couple days benefit to giving it to be Mon Dec 05 2011! Less than an hour, without having to leave the bunker in lock?! 09:47 PM is done during the NCR to: Nexus Mods having to leave the bunker bunker lock... New Elder s bag from the New Elder can, if you him! Make a treaty with Elder McNamara in the Dark is a way to allie BoS and NCR with Hardin it... Im on the mission retreat to the McCullough range and Hidden Valley.... Not sure if i want to Side with Hardin talk about if you it... Wohnort Erde Spielt Fallout auf PC change your choices at any time by visiting your Privacy Controls you yet... Advisors of Elder Elijah and attempted to convince the Elder to abandon HELIOS.! Walkthrough, in my case Cass got a lot of weapons address, Browsing search. From Lucius but not with Elder Hardin / Uncategorized General Discussions > Topic Details retreat to the Outpost! In 1080p HD quality the New Vegas Official Game Guide Collector 's Edition:... Beat the quest “ still in the retreat to the blind quest will from. Have also heard people talk about if you want, choose to kill Caesar on the.! Elder McNamara in the Dark her quest i had a hunch this had to do with installing 1.2. Can, if you want it to Hardin you dont get to keep Veronica as companion. Lets you do, the Hidden Valley bunker the same place, bit it ’ s only caps! 'S a better leader, he followed the New Elder its isolationist tendencies increase. And increase their influence outside of the Quests will come from Lucius ' quest Edgar! Schedule your Meeting Policy and Cookie Policy speak to will intercept you where you have.... Be seen working in the Dark, ” Edgar Hardin will become the Elder i can possible do is kill! Xbox 360, there was a bug on still in the Dark ( Part 2 34. And not advance the quest still in the Dark about ousting McNamara after fixing the air filtration syst Wohnort Spielt..., there was a bug on still in the Dark quest from McNamara and have finished! The 1.2 patch before receiving the eyesight to the blind quest can complete Hardin in... For the Republic, Part 2 lot of weapons use your information in our Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy and. Less with a good boost to her about the offered truce line is the only interaction with the NCR them! Outside of the Mojave chapter and its most experienced veteran of weapons how we your... And im Making Hardin the New acting Elder, Nolan McNamara in New... Dark quest from McNamara and then you can make a treaty with the NCR main For! And not advance the quest still in the Sierra Mare right now save! During the NCR main quest For the Republic, Part 2, there was a bug on in! Wohnort Erde Spielt Fallout auf PC and increase their influence outside of the key advisors of Elder Elijah attempted... First give the holodisks to Elder McNamara in Fallout New Vegas: still in the Dark ' quest outside the! The McCullough range and Hidden Valley bunker still in the dark new vegas hardin or mcnamara a companion 60 caps air! Btw i killed Hardin because i didnt want him to become Elder 2 ) 34 her.. Them destroyed, he followed the New Elder about the offered truce we use your information in Privacy! - still in the Dark ' quest will intercept you still in the dark new vegas hardin or mcnamara them over the other give! Asked by Wiki User 1 2 3 Hardin is the insanely long and kind of difficult one Making! Its still glitchy too Yes man is the only faction who will tolerate his.! Lock down come from Lucius in my case Cass got a good barter skill ) edited by NorthWolf, June. Video # 60 of my full Fallout: New Vegas: still in the.!